15-502 Technology and Global Development

Spring 2009 - Qatar Edition
 
 
Home   |   Instructors and TA   |   Lectures

Assignments   |   Schedule   |   Resources
 

Assignments:

Class Preparation - 19 March (Thursday)

Technology Design
http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/jeff_han_demos_his_breakthrough_touchscreen.html
http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/dean_kamen_on_inventing_and_giving.html

Questions
Jeff Han "Unveiling the genius of multi-touch interface design"
  1. What kind of applications can you envision for this technology?
  2. Jeff stated that interfaces should adapt to us rather than the other way around. Can you envision what this might mean for ICTD?

Dean Kamen "Rolling along, helping students and the third world"
  1. What kinds of problems does a Segway solve?
  2. What problems have been encountered trying to disseminate this technology solution?
  3. How might these problems carry over to implementation or dissemination of other solutions?



Class Preparation - 17 March (Tuesday)

Technology Infrastructure
http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/neil_gershenfeld_on_fab_labs.html
http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/david_merrill_demos_siftables_the_smart_blocks.html


Questions
Neil Gershenfield: "Beckoning promise of personal fabrication"
  1. What are some of the technology innovations that Neil is working on?
  2. What does his ideas have to do with ICTD? Can this really be IT development for the masses?
  3. Neil claims the result of personal fabrication yields the potential to “locally design and produce solutions to local problems.” Explain what he means.

David Merrill "Siftables, the toy blocks that think"
  1. How is playing with blocks problem solving?
  2. What are siftables?
  3. What can you do with siftables?
  4. How could these be used in ICTD?


Case Study Assignment

Case Study Assignment PDF File
Assigned: March 10, 2009
Update Due: Before midnight, April 2, 2009
Please make sure the professors receive your submission.


Class Preparation - 12 March (Thursday)

Read: http://people.ischool.berkeley.edu/~parikh/papers/chi1104-bderenzi.pdf



Class Preparation - 10 March (Tuesday)

Read: http://tier.cs.berkeley.edu/docs/ict4d06/speech_recognition_illiterate-mp.pdf



Final Project

Final Project PDF File
Assigned: Feb 24, 2009
March 19 : Report on background research, needs assessment and finalized project scope

April 2: Report on related work, solution options and chosen solution

Update Due: In class, April 7, 2009

April 9: Report on capacity building and sustainability plan

April 16: Report on monitoring and evaluation plan

Draft Report and Presentation Due: In class, April 21, 2009

Final Report and Presentation Due: Before midnight, April 30, 2009


Peer Evaluation Form: Download!


Class Preparation - 3 March (Tuesday)

Read: http://extension.osu.edu/~hcrd/people/staff/Sachs-End%20of%20Poverty.pdf
Watch: http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/bill_clinton_on_rebuilding_rwanda.html

Questions:

"The End of Poverty"
Jeffrey D. Sachs
  1. What is the method that Jeffrey says we need to adopt in order to end poverty by the year 2025?
  2. What are some of the misconceptions about the causes of poverty?
  3. How does Jeffrey characterize those in "extreme poverty"?
  4. What are the five development interventions advocated by Jeffrey?
  5. Do you agree with the myths about poverty presented? Why? Why not?
  6. Do you think his steps will accomplish the end of poverty? Why? Why not?

Talks Bill Clinton: TED Prize wish: Let's build a health care system in Rwanda
  1. "We live in a world which is interdependent but insufficient." What did he mean? What three areas were explicitly enumerated?
  2. What does Bill see as a far bigger problem in poor countries than corruption? Why?
  3. What kind of health care system does he want to build in Rwanda?
  4. Whose model did he use in implementing health care in Rwanda? Why?
  5. How long does he say it will be before these systems are sustainable without foreign aid? Why?


Class Preparation - 24 February (Tuesday)

Watch the following videos:
  1. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=By6qtBafak8
  2. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oYtfviYA38Q
  3. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4wxo5IHpT0
Questions
Riz Khan: "Princess Maxima, Microfinance & 'The Unbanked'"
  1. What is microfinance? Microcredit?
  2. According to Princess Maxima, why is it important for the world’s poorest to have access to banking or financial services?
  3. According to Roshaneh Zofar, what has been the impact of microfinance on the world’s poor?
  4. What were some of the challenges Roshaneh faced in setting up her microfinance business?
"Senegal Ecovillage Microfinance Fund"
  1. How was the fund started?
  2. Why was it successful?
"Microfinance: Does It Really Work?"
  1. What is seen as a major drawback to microfinance system compared to traditional banks?
  2. Why is a high interest rate typically charged by some microfinance persons?
  3. How do the locally owned microfinance groups differ from a MFI?
  4. What were some of the problems with microfinance that were discussed in the video?
  5. What were the claims that microfinance falls short in eradicating poverty?


Class Preparation - 19 February (Thursday)

Watch the video:
http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/paul_collier_shares_4_ways_to_help_the_bottom_billion.html
Paul Collier: "4 Ways to improve the lives of the 'bottom billion' "
Questions:
  1. Paul states that to give hope to the billion living at the bottom he proposes an 'alliance of compassion and enlightened self-interest'. What did he mean? What example did he use?
  2. According to Paul there are 4 areas needed for effective policies. What are they?
  3. Which of these does he then choose to discuss? Why?
  4. What is the 'resource curse'? When does this occur? Why (according to Paul)?
  5. What was the effect of democracy on resource booms? What aspect of democracy seemed to do the most damage?
  6. What is his solution?



Class Preparation - 17 February (Tuesday)

Watch the video:
http://www.ted.com/talks/bill_gates_unplugged.html
Bill Gates: "How I am trying to change the world now"
Questions:
  1. Bill makes the statement: "The market does not drive the scientists, communicators, thinkers, governments to do the right things." What did he mean?
  2. Why was malaria eradicated from the non-temperate zones?
  3. Why do tools (for example for fighting malaria) eventually become ineffective?
  4. Why does new tools alone (for fighting malaria) not provide the roadmap to get rid of the disease?
  5. What does Bill Gates state that it will take to eradicate or severely reduce malaria worldwide?
  6. Why does Bill Gates claim that the key to educating the masses revolves around having ‘good teachers’?
  7. How does Bill suggest to use technology to help teachers improve?


Capacity Building Assignment - UPDATED

Capacity Building Assignment PDF File
Assigned: Feb 10, 2009
Due: Before midnight, February 26, 2009
Please make sure the professors receive your submission.

Class Preparation - 12 February (Thursday)

  1. Read http://tier.cs.berkeley.edu/docs/ict4d06/social_development_kerala-rk.pdf
  2. Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DygAgWi4Tbo
  3. Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDyN2yux_NY
  4. Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vpqO8Fnq9E&NR=1

Questions
"Integrating Social Development and Financial Sustainability" by Renee Kuriyan, Kentaro Toyama, and Isha Ray
  1. What are the dilemmas and tradeoffs facing ICT projects at the 'macro level' (state and political parties) and 'micro level' (entrepreneurs and potential consumers)?
  2. How did the socially-driven entrepreneurs view the government role in the kiosks? How did the business-driven entrepreneurs view their telecenters? How does the balance driven entrepreneur balance social development with business viability?
  3. How did the consumers generally view the Akshaya project?
"Technology Boosts Income, Reduces Poverty"
  1. How does technology boost income?
  2. How does it reduce poverty?
  3. Is the video an accurate assessment of technology's impact on developing communities and poverty?
"Robot Spyplanes Get New Role as Medical Couriers"
  1. How does this use of technology fit with your idea of ICTD?
"Cell Phones Battle Poverty (You Can Hear Me Now)"
  1. How are cell phones battling poverty?
  2. How has the cell phone become a bank?
  3. How do you envision the cell phone aiding the poor?


Class Preparation - 10 February (Tuesday)

  1. Read http://www.i4donline.net/nov05/ictdnewsletter.pdf
  2. Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QW3c1QHvSqc
  3. Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wBmWlI16JM8
  4. Watch http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qIuRbiX9px4

Questions
"Impact Assessment of ICT for Development Projects" ICTD Project Newsletter
  1. What are the difference between monitoring and evaluation? Why are both needed?
  2. Why are participatory techniques necessary for evaluations to be effective?
  3. What is e-Governance? Why is a 'rational assessment framework' important for e-Governance projects? What is the purpose of the assessment?
"Microsoft Research Project: Mischief"
  1. What novel approach did Microsoft use in its Multipoint project?
"Social Entrepreneur of the Year in India 2008" – Brij Kothari
  1. How was same language subtitling (SLS) used to increase literacy?
  2. What was Brij's contribution?
"Patrick Awuah '89 on Leadership in Africa"
  1. Why did Patrick feel that education of leaders is of utmost importance particularly in developing communities?
  2. Why should we strive for perfection (even though it is impossible)?


Class Preparation - 5 February (Thursday)

Thursday's class will be dedicated to discussing the strategy for the Campaign Assignment . You will lead most of this discussion so please come prepared with your team structure, top three ideas for the campaign design, and strategy for task allocation within your group. Part of our goal with this assignment is to teach you how to work effectively in a group so we want to devote some class time to help you learn how to do this.

Read the following papers
  1. http://www.viktoria.se/altchi/submissions/submission_indranimedhi_0.pdf
  2. http://www.cs.colorado.edu/department/publications/reports/docs/CU-CS-1006-06.pdf
  3. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpRRivQgpjc&feature=related
  4. http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/iqbal_quadir_says_mobiles_fight_poverty.html

Questions:

Reading 1
Full-Context Videos for First-Time, Non-Literate PC Users
Indriani Medhi & Kentaro Toyama

  1. What are the problems for non-literate PC users?
  2. How were full-context videos used to overcome perceived problems?
  3. Why was the job application concept selected as the means of testing the full-context video concept?
Reading 2
AIR: Advancement through Interactive Radio
S. Revi Sterling, John O'Brien & John K. Bennett

  1. Why was a project for empowering women in Kenya chosen? Why do you agree (or disagree) with their rationale?
  2. Why did the authors choose to use radio?
  3. What are some factors that contributed to the success of this project?
Video
One Laptop Per Child: Zimi's Full Story

  1. Was this a full story? Why? Why not?
Video 2
Iqbal Quadir: The Power of Mobile Phone to End Poverty

  1. What was the speaker's answer to 'Why does poverty persist?'
  2. What was his solution? i.e. How can citizens be empowered?
  3. Why did he believe that telephones would aid/empower citizens?
  4. How was this ultimately implemented in Bangladesh?
  5. What are some of the myths about the poor pointed out the speaker?


Class Preparation - 3 February (Tuesday)

Read the following papers
  1. http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=4548168&isnumber=4548155
  2. http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=4548169&isnumber=4548155
  3. One more reading - Sent to you via e-mail
  4. Watch the video at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UjWcmaVfMyY

Questions:

Reading 1
Information and Communication Technologies for Development
Kentaro Toyama & M. Bernadine Dias

  1. Who is the 'development' in ICTD?
  2. Why should "access to information" be considered a fundamental human right?
  3. What constitutes ICT?
  4. How can ICT have a positive impact on the less fortunate that survive on less than a dollar a day?
  5. How would you describe the ICTD field?
Reading 2
ICT4D 2.0: The Next Phase of Applying ICT for International Development
Richard Heeks

  1. What lessons were learned from the ICT4D 1.0 projects?
  2. In what areas will hardware innovations be required for ICT4D 2.0?
  3. What are the 4 main development roles ICT4D is slowing moving toward?
  4. What are the pro-poor, para-poor, and per-poor innovation efforts? Examples?
  5. What are the three areas or disciplines involved in creating ICT4D success? What is the role of each? Why is each needed?
  6. What is the most prominent difference between ICT4D 1.0 and ICT4D 2.0?
Reading 3
The Emerging Field of ICTD
M. Bernadine Dias & Eric Brewer

  1. What are some of the questions being addressed in the ICTD field? How is information communication technology being applied to problems traditionally addressed in development?
  2. What is the role of computer science in ICTD?
  3. Who (what fields) are involved in ICTD? What is their role?
  4. What are some of the challenges of ICTD?
  5. What are some of the issues involved in trying to make ICTD projects sustainable?
Video

  1. What makes TechBridgeWorld projects different from traditional help to developing communities?


Class Preparation - 29 January (Thursday)

Read “Banker to the Poor” Chapter 7 (pp. 117-123)
  1. How did the state of the government in Bangladesh affect the establishing of the Grameen Bank?
  2. Who was A. M. A. Muhith? What role did he play in helping Yunus establish the Grameen Bank?
  3. Was the bank established as envisioned by Yunus? What were the differences in the bank created and the one Yunus desired?
  4. Were all the problems ultimately resolved to Yunus’ liking?
  5. What was Muhith’s promise regarding the bank? Was he able to keep his promise? Why or why not?
  6. What lessons can you take away from Yunus’ experiences in the establishment of the Grameen Bank?
  7. What did you learn from the pictures?


Campaign Assignment

Campaign Assignment PDF File
Assigned: January 27, 2009
Topic Choice Due: In class, February 3, 2009
Report Due: By the end of class, March 5, 2009

Peer Evaluation Form: Download!

Media Assignment

Media Assignment PDF File
Assigned: January 27, 2009
Due: In Class, February 12, 2009

Class Preparation - 27 January (Tuesday)

Watch the video “Waters of Ayole”
  1. What were some of the problems with the way water was supplied to the villagers at the beginning of film?
  2. How was clean water brought to the village?
  3. What problems (and for whom) arose with this solution?
  4. Why did this solution fail?
  5. Who initiated finding out why the project failed (i.e. why the pumps were not repaired)?
  6. What were the problems? Why was there no resolution to these problems?
  7. Who initiated a possible solution to broken pumps in Ayole? What were the attitudes (initially) of the workers sent in to facilitate helping the villagers have clean water? What were the attitudes of the villagers?
  8. Identify the stakeholders in the second solution. What was the role of each?
  9. Why was this solution successful?
  10. What were other benefits resulting (than clean water) from this solution?


Class Preparation - 21 January (Thursday)

Watch the movie “Children of Heaven” by Majid Majidi (available on reserve at the library)
  1. What in the movie matched your view of living in poverty? Was there anything that did not match your view of poverty?
  2. What were the challenges of the family in the movie? Would you consider these challenges unique to living in poverty? Unique to living in Tehran?
  3. Consider how the relationships were depicted in the film. Were they similar or different than you would expect?
  4. Would you consider the film to be a real depiction of poverty? A romanticization of a poor community?


Class Preparation - 19 January (Tuesday)

Before doing the reading, think about your images of poverty.
  • What words would you use to describe people living in poverty?
  • What images would you anticipate seeing in a story of poverty?


  • Read the following sections of “Banker to the Poor” by 2006 Nobel Peace Prize winner Mohammed Yunus: Introduction, Chapter 3&4.
    1. What were the author's motivations for studying the poor (surveying Jobra’s economy)?
    2. Why do economists usually not consider the issues of poverty and hunger?
    3. How did Yunus plan to assist the villagers of Jobra overcome the famine? How did the villagers view his plan? Why?
    4. What strategies did Yunus use to overcome challenges?
    5. Why did Yunus’ experience with Jobra’s deep tubewell lead him to concentrate on the landless poor?
    6. Why was trying to help the women particularly difficult?
    7. Why would the banks not lend to the poor?


    Research Assignment

    Research Assignment PDF File
    Assigned: January 13, 2009
    Community Selection Due: In class, January 15, 2009
    Report Due: Before midnight (via email to one or both instructors), January 29, 2009
    Please make sure the professors receive your submission.

    Pre-Assessment

    Pre-Assessment PDF File
    Done in-class